Secondary school is one of the most important stages in a child’s education, shaping their GCSE performance and opening doors for future opportunities.
With Ofsted no longer publishing single-word ratings, The Telegraph has created a new secondary school league table for 2025.
This ranking uses a unique 40-point scoring system built on 10 key indicators, including GCSE results, class sizes, and pupil progress. It allows parents to see how schools near Derby compare against national standards, and to make confident, informed choices.
Out of almost 3,500 state secondaries in England, just five schools nationally achieved the maximum 40 points. In and around Derby, nine schools stood out as the worst local performers in GCSE results.
We’ve focused on the ones rated ‘Well below average’ or ‘below average’ rated schools by the Telegraph’s new league table, with low scores out of 40.
See the full national league table here.

5. Noel-Baker Academy - 'Well below average'
This school has a lower percentage of pupils getting 5s or higher in their English Baccalaureate. Telegraph rating 14/40, Attainment 8 score: 35.2 | Google
6. City of Derby Academy - 'Well below average'
This school has a lower percentage of pupils getting 5s or higher in their English Baccalaureate. According to The Telegraph - Attainment 8 score: 32.3, 15/40 rating. | Google

7. Castle Donington College - 'Below average'
This school has a lower percentage of pupils getting 5s or higher in their English Baccalaureate. Telegraph says: Attainment 8 score, 42.4. Rating: 20/40 Photo: David Jones

8. The Long Eaton School - 'Below average'
The Long Eaton School saw Progress 8 score of 0.33 below national average. The school had 193 KS4 pupils on its roll and has been rated 'requires improvement' by Ofsted since February 2024. This school has a lower percentage of pupils getting 5s or higher in their English Baccalaureate The Telegraph rating: 21/40 Photo: Google


