Major update on battery farm plan for Roman Fort site in Derbyshire
A battery energy farm on the site of a Roman fort has been rejected with fears the surrounding Derbyshire countryside will be consumed by industrial complexes
A battery energy farm on the site of a Roman fort has been rejected following fears that the surrounding Derbyshire countryside will be consumed by industrial complexes.
At a South Derbyshire District Council meeting last night, plans from international firm Tag Energy for a gigawatt battery energy farm comprising 194 shipping containers off Main Street, Walton, were unanimously rejected.
The facility, between Walton, the former Drakelow Power Station and the River Trent, is aimed at supporting an increase in renewable energy.
However, concerns over the loss of valuable agricultural land, landscape impact, flooding, construction traffic, fire hazards and wildlife saw the scheme refused by councillors.
A Roman fort has been identified on part of the site and this will mean parts of the development would involve “no-dig” zones, which councillors claim would be unviable when cabling for the facility will be underground to the neighbouring power station. Historic England and Derbyshire County Council archaeologists have not objected to the plans.
Cllr Neill Forrest, of Walton Parish Council, told the meeting that the facility would generate enough electricity to power 15,000 Tesla cars and claimed it would “destroy the countryside”.
He claimed: “All rural villages will effectively coalesce with energy infrastructure.”
Cllr Forrest said the scheme would be too close to the 2,000-home housing site on the former Drakelow Power Station, which he said would need to be evacuated if the facility caught fire.
An agent for the applicant told the meeting that geopolitical tensions had made energy supplies volatile and that the UK needed to prioritise domestic energy provision and decarbonisation plans.
He said it was “challenging” to find a suitable site for such a development which is not in a flood zone, flat and largely concealed from view and near National Grid infrastructure.
The agent claimed there was no other viable site within 3 kilometres and that the owner of the former power station had rejected an approach to build there instead – on heavily industrial brownfield land.
Cllr Amy Wheelton said: “There are serious cumulative impact issues on best and most versatile agricultural land loss, traffic, impact on protected species and landscape and visual impact.
“I do not accept that the public benefit outweighs the harm.
“This will be one of the first things you will see as you sweep across the river Trent into South Derbyshire: this picture of an urbanised industrial development at the entrance to the gateway into South Derbyshire and the National Forest.”
She said the claim that the land could be returned to its current condition after its planned 40 years of use was “insulting and laughable” to “anyone that has any understanding of soil, farming and the land”, due to the compression of the soil by heavy machinery and shipping containers.
“The proposals undoubtedly represent a fundamental change from agricultural to an industrial use, but they also add to a coalescence of the merging of Drakelow with Walton on Trent.”
She said the scheme represents a “long-term generational change in the landscape”.
Cllr Alistair Tilley said: “Here we go again, just another BESS (battery energy storage system) and the assault on the South Derbyshire countryside continues.”
He claimed the application represented part of the “piecemeal grabbing of sites by investment companies for profit” and was leading to an inefficient array of applications.
Cllr Andrew Kirke said: “We are seeing a proliferation of these sites in the area. We are losing sight of the cumulative effect and the capacity and need.”
Cllr Alan Jones said that following the recent approval of the 472-acre Oaklands solar farm between Walton and Rosliston, every new piece of lost agricultural land was “substantial” in the context of the local area.
In November, councillors rejected a further battery energy farm nearby, directly adjacent to the former power station, for a 200 megawatt facility, which is now being appealed by the developer.