Chef who makes 'Derby's best pizza' reveals customers' favourite toppings - and they might surprise you
Pizza Pony Derby serves authentic Neapolitan wood-fired pizza
A Derby chef whose pizzas have earned him the coveted accolade of ‘best pizzas in the Midlands’ has revealed his bestselling toppings - plus one that you wouldn’t expect.


Paolo Cacace, 39, from Allestree, is owner of The Pizza Pony in Derby.
The chef always been in the trade. He started the business with his partner of 20 years Lauren McCoy, who he met at school and with whom he shares three children.
According to Paolo, spicy sausage is a wildly popular pizza topping that hungry diners order from his busy pizza business that he operates from Mr Grundy’s pub in Derby.
Spicy meat and white pizza are top sellers at Pizza Pony Derby
Salami and 'Nduja - a spreadable spicy pork paste hailing from Calabria, southern Italy - are best sellers at Pizza Pony Derby.
He said: “Bestsellers with English people are salami and ‘Nduja.


“We get a lot of Italian customers too, who enjoy salsiccia which is an Italian sausage seasoned with fennel.”
Another pizza that is earning rave reviews from Paolo’s current menu is Mortadella and Burrata pizza.
This is a white pizza which is made without a traditional tomato sauce base and topped instead with white cheeses to give it a white appearance.
Paolo’s Mortadella and Burrata pizza is made with fior di latte mozzarella, mortadella, rocket, burrata and a sprinkling of pistachios for an unexpected nutty twist.
Surprise pizza topping you would not expect
Spicy meat may be a hot favourite for Paolo’s customers, however there is one topping that is something of a surprise.
Specials that Paolo has created in the past, are pizzas topped with… fried aubergine which Paolo said were ‘very popular.’
It is so popular, it is back on the new menu that Paolo launched last week.


Pizza trends to expect in 2024
According to Paolo, Pizza Contemporanea - or Contemporary Pizza - is the new trend in Italian pizza which Pizza Pony strives to serve.
Paolo said: “This is Neapolitan pizza with a big airy crust that is crunchy but airy at the same time.
“This is my favourite style of pizza and to make it you need top of the range ingredients such as flour, tomatoes, mozzarella, even the salt needs to be of good quality.
“You need to prove the dough for 24/48 hours at least."
You might also enjoy:
Italian connection
Italy is a place close to Paolo’s heart. He uses ‘only top quality ingredients’ which he sources from Italy, and he even shipped over a specialty wood fired pizza oven from Avellino in the Campania region of southern Italy.
Paolo started the business purely for a love of pizza.
He said: "Pizza is probably my favourite thing to eat.
"I grew up eating it and loving it during my summers in Sorrento, where my Dad was from, and up until quite recently, it was hard to find great pizza here.
“I wanted to sell pizzas like the ones I ate in Sorrento that I would love to eat myself and that’s what I aim to do.”
Paolo’s passion for his craft has seen diners rave about his ‘amazing’ creations on Tripadvisor.
Praises sung about his pizzas include ‘fantastic’ ‘brilliant’ ‘best pizza in the Midlands’ and ‘fabulous wood fired pizza.’


Top tips for making best pizza at home
Paolo says in order to create delicious pizzas, always try to use the best ingredients.
Get the dough right, prove it properly and using a wood fired oven ‘makes all the difference.’
Pizza Pony will be serving pizza at Mr Grundy’s pub, from Thursday to Saturday from 5pm until 10pm.
People can also pick up pizzas by ringing their order in advance and collecting.
Pizza Pony can be found at Mr Grundy’s Pub, the address is 32-36 Ashbourne Road, Derby DE22 3AD
For more information about Pizza Pony visit their social media profile by clicking here.
